Digital devices in education: finding the right balance

Recently, this conversation has moved onto a new level with Greece, Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands and Sweden all implementing phone and personal digital device bans in schools. These restrictions are typically driven by concerns about the negative impact of excessive screen time on students' physical and mental health. Additionally, there are concerns about the potential for distractions and misuse of technology during class time.

The Czech Republic, Finland and Norway have given schools and teachers greater autonomy to make decisions for their individual institutions. Such moves recognise the clear difference between the use of devices to access digital teaching resources vs. social media channels.

These differing approaches to mobile bans across Europe highlight the complexities surrounding the use of digital devices in education. To foster a more informed and balanced approach, it is crucial to engage in nuanced dialogues that involve all key stakeholders. Such discussions should try to give decision makers a clear understanding of available research on the impact of digital devices on learning and student well-being. This would help them to make evidence-based decisions that promote both student engagement and responsible technology use.

But perhaps the key to harnessing the benefits of digital devices, while mitigating the risks, is to establish clear guidelines and policies for their use in schools. Such guidelines should address three key issues. 

1. Device restrictions: Schools may consider implementing restrictions on the use of personal devices during certain times of the day, such as during class time or in specific areas of the school.
2. Appropriate use: Clear guidelines should be established regarding the appropriate use of digital devices in the classroom. Students should be taught how to use technology responsibly and ethically.
3. Supervision: Teachers should monitor students' use of digital devices and intervene when necessary to ensure that they are being used productively.

In conclusion, the debate over the use of personal digital devices in school education is complex and multifaceted. While there are valid concerns about the potential negative impacts of excessive screen time, it's equally important to recognize the benefits that these devices can offer in terms of learning and engagement. By finding a balanced approach that addresses both the risks and the opportunities, schools can ensure that students have access to the resources they need to succeed, while also protecting their physical and mental health.

Signpost is working with schools and local governments across Europe to address these issues - contact us now to see how we could support you.

Source 1 - source 2